data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/bc277/bc277fac761af11a60baf99a6250953e75550ade" alt=""
So why do many fantasy writers like the thought of their tale being set in the Dark Ages? What makes it so appealing?
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/5c957/5c95721bf0339b8bfc653381dc37be89565757ce" alt=""
There are very few historical records from back then, therefore historians know little about it compared to what we know about more recent monarchs such as Henry VIII and Elizabeth I. Because of this, the era has been dubbed 'the dark ages'.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/1ddf3/1ddf326ae18db7100028454cac8bb0b624ce4f8f" alt=""
However, the era does hold one story that has gripped the entire world for centuries; that of King Arthur and the Knights of the Round Table. To this day they have found no evidence to prove that he ever existed, and yet no evidence to say that he didn't either. His story about Camelot, Guenevere, Sir Lancelot and, of course, Merlin, the Sword in the Stone, and the Lady of the Lake, is filled to the brim with mystery, magic, bravery and all things fantastical. Maybe he did rule a fine kingdom with his Knights, or maybe this was the very first fantasy story dreamed up. When comparing it to historical facts, Merlin the Sorcerer definitely sounds like a character from a work of fiction. But people love it and have continued to share the tale throughout generations. And, of course, it was set in a time when people didn't inherit the throne, rather they gained it through other means and deeds.
Maybe, with the story of King Arthur so deeply embedded in our minds, the fantasy genre grew and evolved from here; that the dark ages, because so little is known about it, was a haven for all things mystical and unexplained; that there could have been dragons roaming and sorcerers casting evil spells; that anything was possible. And maybe writers subconsciously want to create a fantasy story so big and fantastical that it will be remembered for thousands of years in the future.
You can't deny it, and as stereotypical as it is, the Dark Ages and Fantasy fit so well together...
I think people like to write in the dark ages because it is a safe return to a time period when people had to struggle and band together in order to survive and where men could treat women like possessions and get away with it. If it ever gets too intense, you can step away. If it ever gets too raw, you can step away. It's safe to explore it in fiction.
ReplyDeleteWow, this is so well thought out and put together. I guess i never thought about it like this but you're right. The mystery of the age mixed with a very popular 'story' that came out of it is the perfect catalyst for the 'typical' fantasy.
ReplyDeleteCultures in flux and with few written records gives imagination more freedom. The pernickity historian in me, however quarrels with this line
ReplyDelete'when came the Roman invasion in the first century with the intention of replacing pagan and Celtic beliefs with Christianity' They didn't invade to bring in Christianity. They were as pagan as the next man. Enforcement of Christianity came with later emperors when the empire was already in decline. For sheer interest it's worth checking out how brutally Christians with imperial authority tried to suppress paganism in Britain - but a few hundred years after the Romans invaded. Puts chalk away and shuts up : )